Do CIOs ever purposefully hinder innovation in order to prevent risk of failure and protect their own career should things go awry?

I had a CIO say to me recently, when talking about a modernization project, "How can you guarantee me that I'm not going to end up in some trade journal as the next grand failure?" So they agree with the objectives of the project, but there's personal risk in not wanting to be the next magazine article about a huge failure. And the flip side of that, that I run into all the time: CIO comes in, they're there for two years, make some decisions, get a project started, and then they leave. And there isn't enough continuity of leadership in order to see this stuff through. Because it starts getting a little dicey and it's the squishy middle that nobody wants to hang around for.

35 views
8 comments
1 upvotes
Related Tags
Anonymous Author
I had a CIO say to me recently, when talking about a modernization project, "How can you guarantee me that I'm not going to end up in some trade journal as the next grand failure?" So they agree with the objectives of the project, but there's personal risk in not wanting to be the next magazine article about a huge failure. And the flip side of that, that I run into all the time: CIO comes in, they're there for two years, make some decisions, get a project started, and then they leave. And there isn't enough continuity of leadership in order to see this stuff through. Because it starts getting a little dicey and it's the squishy middle that nobody wants to hang around for.
0 upvotes
Anonymous Author
There are times when leading an IT organization, where there is that fear that's put into you that if you fail, your job could be on the line. An individual that reports to the CIO of a large financial services institution told me, "My CIO told us, they do not want to be on the front page of The Wall Street Journal. And the individual said, "This caused us to think very differently about the choices we made." And some of those choices were not necessarily the best choices.
0 upvotes
Anonymous Author
Yes. But it is a short-term solution, as the company will likely discover that they are behind the innovation curve.  Innovation-averse CIO’s can have long-term negative effects on the organization. They will move on to their next gig, but their previous firm will have to suffer with the consequences.
0 upvotes
Anonymous Author
Need for speed
1 upvotes
Anonymous Author
It is certainly a risk, but being afraid of failure shouldn't be a stopper.  The board always want to get something in return for every dollar spent and puts pressure on the point. In my experience, the best way to approach this dilemma is by convincing the board that innovation is like a cow that maybe we won't be able to milk but at the end we will be more experienced. Also focus in spend less and fail fast.
1 upvotes
Anonymous Author
I'm sure some might, but I can't ever imagine taking this tact. I'd really innovate and fail then remain status quo and never move the needle.
1 upvotes
Anonymous Author
To me growth and innovation go hand in hand. An individual chairing as a CIO ingrains innovatation into their DNA. Risk of failure for innovation depends on the company culture to penalize or take a stand in the global competition. I believe risk of failure for innovation makes us live consciously.
1 upvotes
Anonymous Author
A long time ago in a very large global Pharma company, the CIO created situations that ensured that the major ERP project did not go live. This continued for 5+ years in which period competitors successfully implemented the same solution. Why did he create such a situation ? His insecurity stemmed from the fact that the legacy system was undocumented in a way that made him a critical resource towards its continuity. If the ERP had gone live, his perceived importance in the company would have diminished. For him the risk was not of failure but to protect his own career and continuity. He was eventually fired but caused a lot of damage to the IT organization credibility which remained an anchor around the neck of newer CIOs for a long time.
2 upvotes